Flooring 101

A Homeowners Guide to Choosing the Right Hardwood Floor Finish

Natural hickory hardwood flooring in a sunlit living room with floor-to-ceiling windows.

Published

November 11, 2026

by Joe Scerri, Owner

How to Choose

A hardwood sample can look soft and understated in the showroom, then catch the afternoon light as soon as you set it down at home. That’s why it helps to look at the finish alongside the wood color. The color gives the floor its tone. The sheen determines how much light you see reflected across it.

‍

If you’re choosing new hardwood floors or refinishing the ones you already have, here’s how to compare matte, satin, and glossier finishes in your own home.

‍

Matte for a low-sheen look

A matte finish reflects less light, which gives the floor a softer appearance. It’s worth sampling if you like the look of natural wood or want the grain and plank pattern to stand out. In a sunny room, look across the sample from a doorway to see how it handles the light coming in from the windows.

‍

If you have pets or a busy entryway, a lower sheen can also make some fine surface marks less noticeable. The wood color matters here, too. Look at both when deciding how much everyday wear you’re comfortable seeing.

‍

Satin for a soft glow

Satin has a gentle sheen that becomes more apparent as you move around the room. It’s a good starting point if you want a little reflection on the floor but still want the wood grain to be easy to see.

‍

Try a satin sample alongside your trim, cabinets, or stair treads. If the hardwood runs through several rooms, carry the sample from one space to the next. A sheen you like in a shaded hallway may look different in a bright living room.

‍

Higher sheen for a more polished look

Semi-gloss and gloss finishes create more visible reflections. That can suit a formal dining room or a space where you want the flooring to have a more polished appearance. The same reflections can also draw attention to fine scratches, dust, or footprints, especially when light hits the floor from the side.

‍

If you like the look of a higher sheen, check it in the busiest part of the room as well as the spot where you first saw it. Think about what you’ll see walking in from the hallway or sitting across from the windows.

Compare the samples where the floor will go

Ask for matte and satin samples in the same wood and color if possible. That makes it easier to see what the sheen changes. Lay the samples flat on the floor and look at them during the day and again with your lights on at night. Step back to a doorway so you can see the reflection from the angle you’ll most often view the floor.

‍

If you’re refinishing existing hardwood, ask your flooring contractor about preparing a test area on the actual floor. That gives you a chance to see the color and sheen on your boards before committing to the whole room.

‍

Daylight from the glass door catches the hardwood beside the staircase.

‍

See the finishes side by side

If you’re deciding between matte and satin or planning to refinish your existing floors, bring a few photos of your rooms to Scerri Quality Wood Floors. We can help you compare finishes and narrow down which samples to take home.

‍

Contact Us →

Related Blogs: Moisture Control and Subfloor Preparation, Glue down vs Nail Down

Leave it to the Pros

We specialize in providing custom, handcrafted hardwood flooring. Gone Finishing handles everything from sourcing, design, installation, and finishing.